Irish eyes still smilin'?
Updated: September 8, 2004, 11:23 AM ET
By
Rod Gilmore | ESPN Insider
It didn't take long for fans and pundits to become cranky during the first full weekend of college football. There was howling about Notre Dame and the Big Ten's instant replay model, while the play of some non-BCS conferences was largely overlooked. Relax, step back and take a closer look at these items.
If you watched Wisconsin dismantle Central Florida, then you saw the first of many quizzes on whether instant replay makes sense in college football. It got mixed results. My colleague Trev Alberts complained that instant replay interrupts the flow of the game. Trev was most incensed that it took several minutes for the "Technical Advisor" to determine where to spot the ball on a particular play. The fact that the coach is not allowed to challenge an official's call is also a problem.
Technical difficulties
If you watched Wisconsin dismantle Central Florida, then you saw the first of many quizzes on whether instant replay makes sense in college football. It got mixed results. My colleague Trev Alberts complained that instant replay interrupts the flow of the game. Trev was most incensed that it took several minutes for the "Technical Advisor" to determine where to spot the ball on a particular play. The fact that the coach is not allowed to challenge an official's call is also a problem.
To continue reading this article you must be an Insider
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
Rod Gilmore serves as an ESPN studio analyst on SportsCenter and College Football Live, and provides commentary on ESPN's Friday night game telecasts. He writes regularly for ESPN Insider.
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE COLLEGE FOOTBALL HEADLINES
- Three Navy players charged in sexual assault
- Vehicle stolen from home of Sooners' Stoops
- Lunt: Gundy lifted restrictions, but too late
- Ex-PSU players support Paternos' lawsuit
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
EDITORS' PICKS

- It's All Relative
- Ivan Maisel, Travis Haney discuss the Future Power Rankings.
Podcast

- Teams Of Tomorrow
- Which teams will rule the next three seasons?
Future Power Rankings

- Clear Skies Ahead
- Sometimes, it only takes one guy to turn a program around.
Woj »
- Future Power Rankings: Top 25 | First 5 out
- Luginbill: Top 10 future college football stars
- Recruiting: Where top prospects will land
- Recruiting: Class Rankings for 2014
- RN: Alabama's post-Saban succession plan


