Why Edgar's not Hall worthy
Despite being a truly great hitter, Edgar Martinez falls short when it comes to Hall of Fame consideration.
Originally Published: August 9, 2004
By Rob Neyer | ESPN Insider
I'll always have a soft spot in my heart for Edgar Martinez.
Back in 1999, not long before the Seattle Mariners moved into their new ballpark, I visited the Mariners' Kingdome clubhouse to ask the players what they thought about Safeco Field. I've always felt like an interloper when I'm in a clubhouse, and so it wasn't easy to approach Ken Griffey to ask for a comment.
Griffey, though, surrounded by attendants and having been given a gag order by management, blew me off. So with my tail between my legs, I looked around the mostly empty locker room for somebody else. Fortunately, Edgar Martinez was among the early arrivals that afternoon, and he didn't mind talking to me.
To continue reading this article you must be an Insider
-
ESPN The Magazine subscribers
-
Need more information?
SPONSORED HEADLINES
MORE MLB HEADLINES
- Yanks' Tex goes on DL; surgery for Youkilis
- Harvey takes no-no into 7th, Mets hold on
- San Jose sues MLB over vote on A's move
- Braves put Gattis on 15-day DL for oblique
MOST SENT STORIES ON ESPN.COM
EDITORS' PICKS

- So Simple, Yet So Complex
- How well do we know the rules?
Jayson Stark »

- A Realistic View
- What can be expected from Wil Myers and Zack Wheeler?
Law

- There Can Be Only One
- Mattingly vs. Girardi is a rematch of their 2007 showdown.
Marchand »
- Law: Expectations for Wheeler, Myers and Cole
- Szymborski: Calculating Kershaw's worth
- MLB Draft: Rodon, Turner could make history
- Olney: New low for A's ballpark
- Swydan: San Diego's sneaky-deep lineup
