Page 2's official report on the officials   

Updated: May 27, 2008, 12:31 PM ET

Blown calls. Instant replay. Those chants from the hometown fans. More than ever, it seems that refs and umps have become a part of the game instead of just enforcing the rules.

So Page 2 decided to ask you --the fans -- what you think of the state of officiating in sports today. Vote early and often.


1) Should baseball have instant replay on home runs?

Yes
No

2) Which sport's officials wrongly influence a game the most?

NFL
NBA
MLB
NHL

3) If every call was correct, would you want a robot camera calling balls and strikes?

Yes
No

4) Do you boo umpires and officials at pro sporting events?

Yes
No
Only when they really, really screw up

5) Do you boo umpires and officials at Little League, high school or college games?

Yes
No

6) Have you ever been reprimanded by security or others for yelling at umpires and officials?

Yes
No

7) Have you ever worked as an umpire or official?

Yes
No

8) Which bad example of officiating still irritates you the most?

NBA Finals Heat-Mavericks, 2006
Steelers-Seahawks Super Bowl
Kings-Lakers Western Conference finals, 2002
The Jeffrey Maier game
Brett Hull's Stanley Cup-winning goal in the crease, 1999
Olympic boxing, any year

9) Whom do you dislike most?

Umpires and officials
Lawyers
Politicians
Telemarketers

10) Given the Tim Donaghy scandal, how much trust do you have in the neutrality of officials?

I have little doubt that the majority of officials are uncompromised
I think there are other Donaghys out there, but it's isolated
I have serious doubts that creep into every game I watch

11) Do you believe a league office would ever influence its refs to affect the results in a desired way?

Yes
No

12) What is the toughest call in sports?

Balls/strikes in baseball
Holding in football
Block/charge in basketball
Something in hockey

13) If instant replay lengthens the game, but increases accuracy, are you in favor of wider use of replay?

Yes
No
Yes, but with a strict time limit
Yes, but only in the playoffs

14) Should there be a mandatory age limit for umpires/referees?

Yes
No

15) If so, what do you believe the age limit should be?

40
50
60
70
Higher

16) Should the public be made aware of any discipline a league takes against officials?

Yes
No
Yes, but keep the names anonymous

17) What tactic is most in need of reform?

Flopping in the NBA
Holding in the NFL
Umps with differing strike zones in MLB
Fighting in the NHL